Restorative Practices for the Seven Generations to Come

June 23, 2022

If you pay attention to the local and national press on restorative practices, as we do, you will see that a debate is growing about its implementation in schools across the country.  The debate, and the lack of understanding regarding the potential impact of restorative practices is evidenced in this recent news segment on “Morning in America.” If you have been doing this work in schools over the past decade, you’ve seen this moment coming.  Schools embrace restorative practices as a way to “solve their discipline problem”, they receive some surface level training, they begin to “do restorative practices”, they don’t see the shifts that they were hoping to see right away, and then the conclusion is made that “restorative practices just don’t work.”

As we teach in our trainings, restorative practices are not a quick fix or magic wand with regard to addressing decades of educational inequity, unhealthy school culture, or disproportionality in discipline and student achievement.  Rooted in indigenous practices that have existed for centuries, these practices will not transform a school culture overnight.  At its root, restorative practices are about culture change - intentional and deliberate movement toward a culture of collaboration, rather than exerting power over; inclusion, rather than exclusion; support and healing, rather than shame and blame; teaching, rather than punishing; voluntary participation, rather than coercion.  

We have to be clear that the implementation of restorative practices is about all of us - teachers, administrators, students, families and school communities - working to change our mindset about how we view school culture, behavior and discipline, as much as it is about changing systems and structure to incorporate more restorative approaches.  The problems that plague our schools were not created overnight and so we should be wary of anyone promising immediate results.

Unfortunately, just as this debate is growing across the country, companies and organizations that promote pre-packaged and canned “restorative practices” are also growing.  The surface level solutions offered by these companies will be ineffective in addressing the root causes of the problems that must be addressed if we hope to positively impact school culture, discipline and student achievement.  In addition, as schools move forward with incorporating these “restorative practices,” they likely will not achieve the outcomes that they are seeking and will quickly conclude that “restorative practices just don’t work.”  Restorative practices, rooted in a commitment to educational equity, can help shift school culture, but only if a school community is willing to build restorative school culture over the long term.  It’s not a magic wand.  It’s not a quick fix.

Speaking to this moment and the challenges that we face, Restorative Justice movement leader Dr. Fania Davis says, “History is asking us to become healers. We are so good at causing harm, at every level. We are experts at that. So I want to thank you for answering history’s call so that we will have a future for the seven generations to come.” 

Visit our website to explore resources related to school-based restorative practices implementation and to find out more about GCC’s approach to restorative practices training and implementation.

other blogs and recommended reading

Starting Small Might Aid Gwinett's School Discipline Shift

In this guest column, Smagorinsky dives into the discipline debate roiling Gwinnett County Public Schools.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

GHC to offer courses for RED Restorative Justice Program

Georgia Highlands College has partnered with Rehabilitation Enables Dreams to offer college access to students in the RED Restorative Justice Program.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

“When another person makes you suffer, it is because he suffers deeply within himself, and his suffering is spilling over. He does not need punishment; he needs help. That's the message he is sending.”― Thich Nhat Hanh

Each time we choose to draw near, rather than to send away, we are actively building a new way to be in community together. As we model this way of being in schools, we are shining a light and showing a way for what can be possible in the community as a whole.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Liberatory Consciousness

We cannot do restorative justice work well if we are not also fighting for racial equity in the spaces that we work. Looking through the lens of equity, we find the concept of liberation. This brings up the question, how do we grow our liberatory consciousness?

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Pine Bluff School Introduces 'Restorative Room' to Help Calm Students, De-Escalate Fights

A school in Pine Bluff introduced the 'restorative room' as a way to help encourage kids to process their emotions and get through tough experiences.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Weaver School Embraces ‘Peacemaker Event’ on Campus

In collaboration with the Restorative Justice League of Merced, the “Weaver Peacemaker Event” is an all day event that focuses on educating students to “promote kindness and build a culture of peace on campus.”

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

An Eighth Grade Class Just Exonerated The Last Witch Of The Salem Witch Trials

Massachusetts teacher Carrie LaPierre led her students through a restorative justice project over 300 years after the infamous Salem Witch Trials.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Remembering How to Be Friends: After COVID, One School Uses Talking Circles to Help Kids Reconnect

That predictable, structured place to safely share is critical, especially for students who want to take on society’s bigger challenges, Swearingen said. “It puts us in a spot where we can be vulnerable with each other, and because we can be vulnerable together we can be productive.”

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

NJEA Officers, Community Tour Restorative Justice Montclair

“As a teacher in Wayne and a resident and mayor here in Montclair, I could not be prouder of the leadership that the Montclair Education Association, the Montclair Board of Education, and our students, teachers, educational support professionals, and administrators have taken in showing what restorative justice looks like in action,” [President] Spiller said.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

New Study: Black, Special Ed Students Punished at Greater Rate Through Pandemic

Despite a dramatic decline in suspensions as students moved to remote learning during the pandemic, Black children and those in special education were disciplined far more often than white students and those in general education, according to a recent New York University study.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

LTE: Restorative Justice in Schools

"We need programs and interventions that teach and model skills that will change behavior. Restorative practices are what can transform and guide the prosocial behaviors we want for our children and our communities."

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

NYC's Push for Restorative Justice Was Put to the Test This School Year

Schools like Harvest Collegiate High School have embraced restorative justice and devoted resources to those programs.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

The Stories We Create

When we’re working as a team, we can start in one direction, but we may end up in a completely different direction by the end of the year.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

At This Oakland High School, Restorative Justice Goes Far Beyond Discipline

Fremont High students are even helping young students engage in restorative justice practices.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Valley State First HBCU to Offer Prison College Program in Mississippi

Incarcerated people at two prisons in the Delta will be able to start earning four-year degrees from Mississippi Valley State University this fall for the first time in more than two decades.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Restorative Arlington Partners with Arlington Public Schools to Support Students and Strengthen Restorative Justice in Education

Restorative Arlington has partnered with Arlington Public Schools (APS) to support Restorative Justice in Education. Restorative Arlington has allocated over $140,000 to provide direct services to APS, including services for students who have experienced harm as well as restorative justice training for staff and additional resources.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Praise for One-of-a-Kind Philly Diversion Program Rooted in 2020 Civil Unrest

Criminal justice reform advocates are applauding a diversion program created to resolve the hundreds of felony cases that came out of the civil unrest that followed the murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis in 2020.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Suffolk District Attorney to Pilot Restorative Justice Program

Suffolk District Attorney Kevin Hayden is piloting a restorative justice program in Chelsea District Court and the Charlestown and Roxbury divisions of Municipal Court.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Cash From Criminal Wrong-Doing Will Now Help Coquitlam Kids

Two unique programs that support Tri-City students are getting nearly $60,000 combined, thanks to proceeds of criminal activity.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Restorative Justice Resolves Alleged Assault at Indiana Lake

Restorative justice was successfully used for one of the first times in Indiana to remediate a legal confrontation.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Social Change and Self Care

Letting Go of Myths, Embracing Truths

Shawn Ginwright writes in Yes! Magazine about Four Pivots to Reimagining Justice and Reimagining Ourselves.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

RJ and Gender-based Violence

Restorative Approaches for Gender-based Violence

This blog explores restorative approaches to gender-based violence and the relationship between the restorative justice and transformative justice movements.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Danny's Journey with Restorative Justice

Danny Malec's Recent Interview on "This Restorative Justice Life" with David Ryan Castro-Harris

This Restorative Justice Life is a podcast series that highlights conversations and storytelling with Restorative Justice Practitioners, Circle Keepers, and others about how they bring Restorative Justice philosophy, practices, and values into their personal and professional lives. Hosted by Amplify RJ founder David Ryan Barcega Castro-Harris. Produced by Elyse Martin-Smith.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

School-based Restorative Practices

"I am happy to be with you today."

Feedback from our trainings helps us strengthen them and gives us valuable insights into the needs of the communities we serve.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

School-based Restorative Practices Implementation

COVID is making it harder for schools to practice restorative practices

This article, originally published in Fortune.com, explores a range of added challenges related to restorative practices implementation as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →

Opinion

Where Is the Forgiveness and Grace in Cancel Culture?

A link to an editorial written on 12/28/21 in the New York Times from Michael Eric Dyson, reflecting on Bishop Tutu's approach to apartheid and the limited value of punishment or banishment.

Read full article (LINK OPENS IN A NEW TAB) →